Understanding Your Ownership Rights When a Business Partnership Falls Apart. Starting a business with a partner often begins with shared goals, mutual trust, and the expectation that both owners will have a voice in the company’s future. Unfortunately, disagreements over money, management, business strategy, or personal relationships can turn a successful venture into a serious legal dispute. When that happens, one partner may attempt to take control of the company, exclude the other from important decisions, or even declare that the other partner is no longer an owner.

Please note this blog post should be used for learning and illustrative purposes. It is not a substitute for consultation with an attorney with expertise in this area. If you have questions about a specific legal issue, we always recommend that you consult an attorney to discuss the particulars of your case.

For Michigan business owners, the question is straightforward: Can your business partner legally force you out of your limited liability company (LLC)? The answer depends on the company’s operating agreement, the rights attached to your ownership interest, and Michigan law. Although a partner may have authority to remove another owner from management, that does not necessarily mean the partner can take away the owner’s membership interest or financial rights.

Your Business Partner Cannot Automatically Take Away Your Ownership.
Under Michigan’s Limited Liability Company Act, ownership in an LLC carries legal rights that cannot simply be disregarded because the owners disagree. A member’s ownership interest is distinct from that person’s employment or management position. Consequently, removing a member from day-to-day operations does not automatically eliminate the member’s ownership rights.

Michigan law expressly permits an LLC operating agreement to establish circumstances under which a member may be expelled or otherwise cease to be a member. MCL 450.4509 provides the statutory framework for these    arrangements. ¹ However, the statute does not give one business partner an unrestricted right to expel another simply because the relationship has deteriorated.

For example, suppose two individuals establish an LLC, with each holding a 50% ownership interest. After several years, one partner becomes dissatisfied with the other’s performance and announces that the other partner has been removed from the company. Unless the governing agreements or another applicable legal basis authorize that action, the announcement alone does not terminate the other partner’s ownership interest.

This distinction is especially important when one member controls the company’s bank accounts, customer relationships, or daily operations. Practical control of a business does not necessarily establish legal authority to eliminate another person’s ownership.

The Operating Agreement May Determine Whether You Can Be Removed.
The operating agreement is often the most important document in a dispute between Michigan LLC members. It establishes the contractual relationship among the owners and may govern management authority, voting rights, membership transfers, expulsion procedures, and the circumstances requiring an owner to sell an interest.

Some operating agreements allow removal following misconduct, a material breach of contractual obligations, or another specifically identified event. Others establish procedures requiring notice, a vote, or a mandatory buyout. Whether these provisions are enforceable and have been properly followed depends on the agreement’s actual language and the surrounding circumstances.

Voting rights also deserve particular attention. Under MCL 450.4502, an operating agreement may allocate voting power among members and may give certain members limited or no voting rights. If the agreement does not address voting rights, the general statutory rule for LLCs formed after June 1997 is one vote per member, rather than voting power automatically corresponding to percentage ownership. ²

As a result, a member who owns 60% of an LLC does not necessarily possess 60% of the votes. Nor does majority voting control automatically include the authority to expel a minority owner. Before attempting to remove a member, or responding to a threatened removal, the parties must examine both the governing documents and the specific legal authority for the proposed action.

Removing a Partner as Manager Is Different From Removing an Owner.
One of the most common sources of confusion involves the distinction between managing an LLC and owning part of it. Michigan law permits an LLC to be managed directly by its members or by designated managers. Unless the articles of organization establish manager management, management generally rests with the members, subject to the operating agreement.

In a manager-managed LLC, MCL 450.4403 generally allows members to remove managers with or without cause, unless the operating agreement requires cause. When removal is for cause, the statute imposes specific meeting, notice, and opportunity-to-be-heard requirements. ²

Consider an LLC owned equally by two individuals who also serve as managers. A dispute may arise that results in one individual’s lawful removal from a management position. Even if that removal is valid, the former manager may remain a 50% owner, with continuing rights to distributions, information, and other benefits associated with membership.

Likewise, terminating a member’s employment does not necessarily terminate the person’s ownership. A departing employee who also owns part of the company may retain that interest unless an applicable agreement provides otherwise. These distinctions become particularly important when the remaining owner attempts to treat employment termination as justification for withholding distributions or forcing a surrender of membership interests.

Business disputes sometimes escalate beyond disagreements over management. One owner may change passwords, deny access to financial records, prevent participation in company decisions, or refuse to disclose information about the company’s finances. Although these actions can make it difficult for an excluded member to protect an ownership interest, Michigan law provides important protections.

Under MCL 450.4503, LLC members have statutory rights to obtain specified financial statements and tax filings, request information concerning the company’s financial condition, and inspect certain company records. Members may also obtain other information and, when appropriate, seek a formal accounting of company affairs. The statute establishes requirements concerning reasonable requests, written requests, and inspection procedures. ³

These rights can be particularly valuable when a business partner controls the company’s financial information. A member who suspects that profits are being concealed, company funds are being diverted, or distributions are being withheld may need access to financial records before determining whether further legal action is appropriate.

Not every disagreement over access constitutes unlawful conduct. Nevertheless, intentionally excluding a member from information or financial benefits protected by law or an agreement may provide grounds for judicial relief.

Even when a business partner has substantial management or voting authority, that authority is not unlimited. Michigan recognizes a legal claim commonly known as member oppression, which protects LLC members against certain wrongful conduct by those controlling the company.

MCL 450.4515 allows a member to bring an action in circuit court when controlling members or managers engage in illegal, fraudulent, or willfully unfair and oppressive conduct. The statute defines oppressive conduct in terms of significant actions or a course of conduct that substantially interferes with a person’s interests as a member. Importantly, the statute generally excludes actions permitted by the company’s governing documents, another agreement binding the member, or a consistently applied written company policy.⁴

Depending on the circumstances, conduct involving the diversion of company assets, discriminatory treatment concerning distributions, or improper interference with membership rights may support an oppression claim. However, a business disagreement or an unpopular management decision, standing alone, does not necessarily establish oppression. The relevant question is whether the challenged conduct satisfies the statute’s requirements.

When a member proves grounds for relief, the court has broad authority to fashion an appropriate remedy. That relief may include directing or prohibiting company action, modifying provisions of the operating agreement, ordering the purchase of the affected member’s interest at fair value, awarding damages, or dissolving the company.

A court-ordered buyout can be particularly important when the owners’ relationship has become unworkable, but the underlying business remains financially viable. Instead of forcing the company to close, a buyout may permit one owner to leave while receiving fair compensation for the ownership interest.

The Michigan Supreme Court’s decision in Frank v Linkner, 500 Mich 133; 894 NW2d 574 (2017), provides important guidance concerning the rights of LLC members and the timing of member-oppression claims.⁵

The dispute arose after changes to an LLC’s ownership and financing arrangements subordinated certain members’ interests. Those members later received no proceeds when the business was sold. The Supreme Court considered when their member-oppression claims accrued and whether the claims for monetary damages were timely.

The Court held that a claim for member oppression accrues when the challenged action substantially interferes with the plaintiff’s interests as a member, even if the member has not yet suffered a calculable financial loss. In that case, the alleged interference occurred when the operating agreement was amended, rather than years later when the business was sold.

This decision provides a significant warning to Michigan LLC owners. A member who believes ownership rights have been improperly restricted should not necessarily wait until the company is sold, a distribution is withheld, or a financial loss becomes apparent before seeking legal advice.

For damages claims under MCL 450.4515, the statute generally requires filing within three years after accrual or two years after the member discovers or reasonably should have discovered the cause of action, whichever occurs first, subject to applicable legal exceptions. Delaying action may therefore jeopardize the ability to obtain monetary relief even when the alleged interference occurred earlier.

If another LLC member threatens to remove you, your first priority should be determining precisely what rights you possess and what action your partner is authorized to take. The articles of organization, operating agreement, amendments, ownership records, and relevant communications may establish whether the proposed removal is permitted and whether proper procedures have been followed.

It is also important to distinguish an actual termination of membership from removal as an employee or manager. The legal consequences can differ substantially. A person excluded from daily operations may still retain ownership, voting, information, and financial rights.

Business owners should preserve relevant communications, financial records, and documentation of their ownership interests. Where necessary, counsel can evaluate whether to demand access to records, challenge an unauthorized action, seek court protection against further interference, or pursue a negotiated buyout. In an urgent case, immediate judicial relief may be appropriate to prevent threatened harm while the underlying dispute is resolved.

Equally important, an owner seeking to remove a troublesome partner should not assume that controlling the company provides unlimited legal authority. Improperly attempting to terminate another member’s rights can expose both the controlling individuals and the company to expensive litigation.

A business partner may be able to remove you from management, terminate your employment, or enforce an expulsion provision in a valid operating agreement. But those actions do not automatically establish a right to take your ownership interest without complying with Michigan law and the company’s governing agreements.

When business relationships deteriorate, the difference between lawful management decisions and wrongful interference with membership rights can determine whether an owner retains an interest in the company, receives fair compensation, or has grounds to bring a lawsuit.

At Tishkoff PLC, we represent Michigan business owners, LLC members, and companies in disputes involving ownership rights, operating agreements, member oppression, business divorces, and related commercial litigation. If your business partner has attempted to force you out of your LLC, or you need advice concerning the lawful removal of another member, our attorneys can help evaluate your legal rights and available options.

Contact Tishkoff

Tishkoff PLC specializes in business law and litigation. For inquiries, contact us at www.tish.law/contact/.

Footnotes and Legal Sources:

1- Expulsion and Withdrawal of LLC Members
Michigan Limited Liability Company Act, MCL 450.4509(1)–(2). Section 509 establishes that withdrawal is governed by the operating agreement and expressly authorizes operating agreements to provide for expulsion or other events terminating membership. https://www.legislature.mi.gov/Laws/MCL?objectName=mcl-450-4509

2- Member Voting Rights and Removal of Managers
Michigan Limited Liability Company Act, MCL 450.4502(1), (8); MCL 450.4401; MCL 450.4403(1)–(3). These sections govern voting rights, the distinction between member-managed and manager-managed LLCs, and the procedures for removing managers. https://www.legislature.mi.gov/Laws/Index?ObjectName=mcl-Act-23-of-1993

3-  LLC Members’ Rights to Financial Information and Records
Michigan Limited Liability Company Act, MCL 450.4503(1)–(5). This section provides members with rights to obtain specified financial and tax records, inspect company records, obtain reasonable information concerning company affairs, and seek a formal accounting under appropriate circumstances. https://www.legislature.mi.gov/Laws/MCL?objectName=mcl-450-4503

4-  Protection Against Willfully Unfair and Oppressive Conduct
Michigan Limited Liability Company Act, MCL 450.4515(1)–(2). Section 515 establishes the statutory cause of action for member oppression and authorizes remedies that include fair-value buyouts, damages, modification of governing documents, and dissolution. https://www.legislature.mi.gov/Laws/MCL?objectName=mcl-450-4515

5-  Michigan Supreme Court Decision on LLC Member Oppression
Frank v Linkner, 500 Mich 133, 894 NW2d 574 (2017), Michigan Supreme Court, decided May 15, 2017, Docket No. 151888. https://law.justia.com/cases/michigan/supreme-court/2017/151888.html

This publication is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. You should consult counsel for advice on your specific circumstances.

Prepared by Tishkoff paralegal Kimberley Taschereau, Tishkoff PLC. Reviewed by Tishkoff PLC attorney William G. Tishkoff.